Cavaliers vs. Pacers Odds & Betting Predictions - May 9, 2025

Cavaliers at Pacers

11:30 pm • ESPN

Cleveland Cavaliers

1-4

126

126 - 104

Indiana Pacers

4-1

104

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Cavaliers 1-4	+1	-5.5-109	o232-109	-215
Pacers 4-1	u228.5	+5.5-111	u232-111	+180

Friday 11:30 p.m.

May 09, 2025

Gainbridge FieldhouseIndianapolis

CLE -3.5 (Live)-115

2.61u

Pacers-Cavs Game 3 Overtime YES +1600

0.5u

Make this Pacers -0.1

T.Jerome o12.5 Pts+102

M.Strus u9.5 Pts-111

A.Nembhard o13.5 Pts+100

P.Siakam o18.5 Pts-105

1.05u

Over 113.5 (1H)-110

1.1u

CLE -5-105

1.9u

Under 232.5-110

D.Mitchell To Score 30+ Points Yes+115

2.3u

🔑 D.Mitchell 30+ points +115 (Fanatics) 2u Coming off 2 back to back 30+ point games. If the Cavs dominate like I think they will, he will be a huge part of it. Love the +money value we get

D.Mitchell o29.5 Pts-108

J.Allen u10.5 Rebs-113

J.Allen u24.5 Pts+Rebs+Ast-105

1.05u

I see this as a great sell-high from a role he should’ve saw in Game 2. The Cavaliers are in desperation mode down 0-2, heading into Game 3 on the road. Darius Garland is set to return, and both Evan Mobley and De’Andre Hunter are expected to suit up. With the full starting group active, Cleveland is pushing all chips in to avoid a 0-3 hole. One player likely to revert to a reduced role is Jarrett Allen. In Game 1, the Mobley-Allen double-big lineup logged just 18 minutes and posted a brutal -51.4 net rating. Against a fast, pass-heavy Pacers team, Cleveland needs more spacing and switchability two things Allen struggles with and got destroyed in PnR. Tyrese Haliburton scored 14 of his 20 points last game directly against Allen in pick-and-roll actions. Allen was asked for more in Game 2 which explains his 19 second-half minutes, but this should closer or even lower than 13 minutes like he saw in Game 1 (when Mobley was out). Both Hunter and Dean Wade saw time at the four, reducing reliance on the double-big lineup. With a full rotation tonight, Allen projects for a max of 30 minutes. According to PropsMadness, in games where he plays 24–30 minutes, he averages just 22.7 PRA. #PlayerProps

D.Mitchell To Score 30+ Points Yes+118

0.59u

J.Allen u10.5 Rebs-104

0.52u

Tailing @wheatonbrando

J.Allen u10.5 Rebs-104

7.7rpg vs Indy with Mobley in lineup, just not a great matchup for him in double big lineup with Turner, only 12.7 reb chances. Talked about it on Buckets, was worth waiting for the positive Mobley news but line is dropping so dont wait much longer

J.Allen u10.5 Rebs-105

0.65u

Joining @wheatonbrando

CLE o117.5-114

D.Mitchell o3.5 3pt M+130

1.3u

CLE -167

Under 229.5-110

0.5u

Using the excellent site Money Baller and tailing a bunch of solid under systems, h/t @awang_htx

D.Mitchell To Score 30+ Points Yes-120

0.42u

https://www.actionnetwork.com/nba/nba-player-props-for-donovan-mitchell-tyrese-haliburton-aaron-nesmith-on-friday-may-9-qs Might add here depending on injury report

A.Nesmith o17.5 Pts+Rebs-106

https://www.actionnetwork.com/nba/nba-player-props-for-donovan-mitchell-tyrese-haliburton-aaron-nesmith-on-friday-may-9-qs

T.Haliburton o18.5 Pts-115

0.5u

https://www.actionnetwork.com/nba/nba-player-props-for-donovan-mitchell-tyrese-haliburton-aaron-nesmith-on-friday-may-9-qs

A.Nembhard o18.5 Pts+Ast-125

0.31u

A.Nesmith o12.5 Pts-120

0.3u

Under 226.5-105

CLE -148

0.44u

Under 227-103

A.Nesmith o4.5 Rebs-105

D.Garland o5.5 Ast-108

1.08u

IND +130

1.5u

CLE -2.5-110

0.91u

🚨Free analysis & VIP Picks can be found on our Discord. Link: https://discord.gg/A8v49URQaG Link to VIP (Copy &Paste): https://linktr.ee/moneylinehacks%F0%9F%94%A560% OFF with promo code: Hacks60

CLE -1-110

0.45u

A Stunning Friday Edge for Savvy NBA Bettors
PJ Walsh•
May 9, 2025 UTC
Cavaliers vs Pacers Game 3: Moore's 3 Best Bets for Tonight
Matt Moore•
May 9, 2025 UTC
Cavaliers vs Pacers: +130 Parlay for Game 3 Tonight
Dead President Picks•
May 9, 2025 UTC
4 NBA Best Bets for Friday's Playoff Games
Action Network Staff•
May 9, 2025 UTC

See more NBA Coverage

No props found

NBA Public Betting

Pacers are 4-1 in their last 5 games.
Pacers are 2-3 in their last 5 games against the spread
Pacers are 19-22 in their road games against the spread
The totals have gone OVER in 3 of Pacers' last 5 games
The totals have gone OVER in 21 of Pacers' 41 last games at home

Against the Spread (ATS) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Pacers	36-44-2	17-22-2	19-22	20-28-2	16-14
Cavaliers	48-33-1	22-18-1	26-15	42-31-1	6-2

Over/Under History

	overall	home o/u	away o/u	favorite o/u	underdog o/u
Pacers	45-37	21-20	24-17	23-27	21-9
Cavaliers	50-31-1	25-16	25-15-1	46-27-1	4-4

Straight-Up (ML) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Pacers	10-2	N/A	N/A	35-15	15-15
Cavaliers	5-4	N/A	N/A	60-14	4-4

date	opponent	score	spread	over/under	moneyline
May 6th	@CLE	W 120-119	+5.5 W	O 227	IND +190
May 4th	@CLE	W 121-112	+8.5 W	O 229	IND +280
Apr 29th	MIL	W 119-118	-8 L	O 222	IND -360
Apr 28th	@MIL	W 129-103	+4 W	O 226.5	IND +154
Apr 26th	@MIL	L 101-117	+5 L	U 229.5	MIL +172