Turn your sports knowledge into winning predictions
21+ or 18+ in Certain Locations. 19+ in ON. Please Play Responsibly. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Visit connexontario.ca or Call 1-866-531-2600 in ON.
No Code Needed

Mets vs. Yankees Odds & Betting Predictions - May 16, 2025

Mets at Yankees

11:05 pm • YES

New York Mets

29-17
2
2 - 6

New York Yankees

26-19
6
Starting Pitchers
pitcherteameraw-l
Carlos Rodon logoC.RodonNew York Yankees logo3.175-3
Tylor Megill logoT.MegillNew York Mets logo3.743-4

Mets at Yankees Odds

Spread, Total, Moneyline

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Mets
29-17
+1.5
+1.5-170
o9-108
+124
Yankees
26-19
u9
-1.5+142
u9-111
-147
location pinFriday 11:05 p.m.
May 16, 2025
Yankee StadiumBronx
Mets vs. Yankees Expert Picks
Cam Is Money
Cam Is Money
Last 30d: 107-132-8 (-31.6u)
NYM +0.5 (F5)-120
1u
Greg DiNardo
Greg DiNardo
Last 30d: 84-72-1 (+9.3u)
Under 9-116
1u
Steak Friend
Steak Friend
Last 30d: 229-274-4 (-43.1u)
Under 9-116
1u
Austin Pendergrass
Austin Pendergrass
Last 30d: 87-117-1 (-28.7u)
NYY -152
0.66u
Bet Labs
Bet Labs
Last 30d: 32-30-0 (-3.2u)
Under 9-115
1u
Ryan Sura
Ryan Sura
Last 30d: 56-71-2 (-11.6u)
Under 9-115
1u
Bet Labs
Bet Labs
Last 30d: 32-30-0 (-3.2u)
NYM +125
0.8u
Grant Neiffer
Grant Neiffer
Last 30d: 32-119-6 (+21.5u)
T.Grisham o0.5 HR+450
0.5u
P.Alonso o0.5 HR+350
0.5u
Picks Office
Picks Office
Last 30d: 73-84-4 (-17.4u)
Over 9+100
1u
Mets vs. Yankees tonight = fireworks incoming. Yankees avg 6.5 runs/game (2nd in MLB), lead league in HRs/game. Judge on fire: .412 AVG, 15 HR, 41 RBI. Goldy + Belli add depth. Stadium’s a launchpad, perfect fit for red-hot Yanks offense. Soto returns to the Bronx, heating up: .289 last 12 games. Alonso raking: .311, 9 HR, 1.004 OPS. Mets now top 5 in HRs/game, lead MLB in walks. Doubles machine too—extra base power + traffic on base = runs. Yankees’ Rodón has given up 8 HRs, looked shaky last start (4 ER). Megill rocked lately: 6.19 ERA last 3 starts, 4.42 ERA on road. Allowed HR in 3 straight. Mets 1-4 in his last 5 outings. Total’s gone Over in all 5. Add rivalry energy, loud Bronx crowd, and short porch magic.
MJC Locks
MJC Locks
Last 30d: 7-25-0 (-1.6u)
J.Soto o1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs+100
1u
Soto making his return to Yankee Stadium and I’m expecting some extra motivation for him. He’s covered 2+ HRRs in 9/L12 Games & 7/L8 on the Road. Rodon has been great this season but I still think Soto & the Mets can find success. Soto is hitting .353 vs lefties on the season & hits Rodon’s pitch mix well. The also Mets rank 4th in wRC+ vs lefties.
Brian Bitler
Brian Bitler
Last 30d: 81-90-0 (-26.0u)
NYM +120
3u
Top Shelf Action 🥃
Top Shelf Action 🥃
Last 30d: 328-541-15 (-12.7u)
NYY -130
1u
Opponent got Upset Overall: 159-75-0,68% (ROI:22%) Season:4-0-0,100% (ROI:71%)
Sean Zerillo
Sean Zerillo
Last 30d: 148-165-8 (-8.7u)
Over 8.5-120
0.6u
Bet to 9 (-110)

Mets vs. Yankees Previews & Analysis

  • Mets vs. Yankees: Subway Series Parlay article feature image

    Mets vs. Yankees: Subway Series Parlay

    Chilly Bets•
    May 16, 2025 UTC
  • 4 Home Run Prop Bets & Parlay for Friday article feature image

    4 Home Run Prop Bets & Parlay for Friday

    Grant Neiffer•
    May 16, 2025 UTC
  • Friday's MLB Best Bets article feature image

    Friday's MLB Best Bets

    Action Network Staff•
    May 16, 2025 UTC
See more MLB Coverage Right Arrow

Prop Odds Comparison

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

No props found

Line Movement Tracker

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Mets vs. Yankees Public Betting Percentages

Away Logo

Mets

Public

Home Logo

Yankees

32%

Bets%

68%

Money%

MLB Public Betting Right Arrow

Betting Trends

  • Yankees are 3-2 in their last 5 games.
  • Yankees are 2-3 in their last 5 games against the spread
  • Yankees are 10-12 in their road games against the spread
  • The totals have gone OVER in 1 of Yankees' last 5 games
  • The totals have gone OVER in 10 of Yankees' 23 last games at home

Matchup History

Against the Spread (ATS) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees		23-2213-1010-1221-182-4
Mets		22-2412-1010-1415-197-5

Over/Under History

overallhome o/uaway o/ufavorite o/uunderdog o/u
Yankees		20-23-210-1310-10-218-20-12-3-1
Mets		16-29-17-14-19-1516-17-10-12

Straight-Up (ML) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees		26-1914-912-1025-141-5
Mets		29-1717-512-1223-116-6

Last 5 Matchups

dateopponentscorespreadover/undermoneyline
May 14th@SEAW 3-2-1.5 LU 8NYY -115
May 14th@SEAL 1-2-1.5 LU 7.5SEA -145
May 13th@SEAW 11-5-1.5 WO 8NYY -152
May 11th@ATHW 12-2-1.5 WO 11NYY -148
May 10th@ATHL 7-11-1.5 LO 10ATH -165

Mets vs. Yankees Injury Updates

Mets Injuries

  • Frankie Montas
    SP

    Montas is out with back

    Out

  • Sean Manaea
    SP

    Manaea is out with oblique

    Out

  • Paul Blackburn
    SP

    Blackburn is out with knee

    Out

  • Jose Siri
    CF

    Siri is out with leg

    Out

  • Nick Madrigal
    3B

    Madrigal is out with shoulder

    Out

  • Ronny Mauricio
    SS

    Mauricio is out with knee

    Out

  • Christian Scott
    SP

    Scott is out for season with elbow

    Out for Season

Yankees Injuries

  • Gerrit Cole
    SP

    Cole is out for season with elbow

    Out for Season

  • Giancarlo Stanton
    DH

    Stanton is out with elbow

    Out

  • Luis Gil
    SP

    Gil is out with back

    Out

  • JT Brubaker
    SP

    Brubaker is out with ribs

    Out

See more MLB Injuries Right Arrow
Mets vs. Yankees Box Score
Mets Player Stats
Projected
PITCHERPCIPKER
Tylor Megill logoRT.Megill, P722.244
Max Kranick logoRM.Kranick, P242.112
Jose Butto logoRJ.Butto, P33210
Dedniel Nunez logoRD.Nunez, P13100
HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
Francisco Lindor logo1F.Lindor, SS1-5001
Juan Soto logo2J.Soto, RF0-2100
Pete Alonso logo3P.Alonso, 1B0-4000
Mark Vientos logo4M.Vientos, 3B1-4000
Brandon Nimmo logo5B.Nimmo, LF2-4001
Starling Marte logo6S.Marte, DH0-4000
Francisco Alvarez logo7F.Alvarez, C0-2100
Luisangel Acuna logo8L.Acuna, 2B0-3000
Brett Baty logo8B.Baty, PH0-1000
Tyrone Taylor logo9T.Taylor, CF1-3000
Jeff McNeil logo9J.McNeil, PH0-0000
Yankees Player Stats
Projected
PITCHERPCIPKER
Carlos Rodon logoLC.Rodon, P102551
Jonathan Loaisiga logoRJ.Loaisiga, P12100
Mark Leiter logoRM.Leiter, P20110
Devin Williams logoRD.Williams, P14130
Yerry De Los Santos logoRY.De Los Santos, P250.221
Luke Weaver logoRL.Weaver, P20.100
HITTERSH-ABRHRRBI
Trent Grisham logo1T.Grisham, CF0-3000
Aaron Judge logo2A.Judge, RF2-4200
Cody Bellinger logo3C.Bellinger, LF3-5200
Paul Goldschmidt logo4P.Goldschmidt, 1B2-4102
Jasson Dominguez logo5J.Dominguez, DH0-2001
Anthony Volpe logo6A.Volpe, SS0-3001
Austin Wells logo7A.Wells, C0-3000
Oswald Peraza logo8O.Peraza, 3B0-3001
Jorbit Vivas logo9J.Vivas, 2B1-4100

Mets vs. Yankees Odds Comparison

Right Arrow

Could not load odds

See more MLB Odds Right Arrow

Mets at Yankees Team Totals

MatchupOverUnder
Mets
29-17
o4.5+114
u4.5-145
Yankees
26-19
o4.5-115
u4.5-115