Turn your sports knowledge into winning predictions
21+ or 18+ in Certain Locations. 19+ in ON. Please Play Responsibly. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Visit connexontario.ca or Call 1-866-531-2600 in ON.
No Code Needed

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Odds & Betting Predictions - May 19, 2026

Blue Jays at Yankees

11:05 pm • YES

Toronto Blue Jays

21-26
@

New York Yankees

29-19
Starting Pitchers
pitcherteameraw-l
Will Warren logoW.WarrenNew York Yankees logo3.425-1
Dylan Cease logoD.CeaseToronto Blue Jays logo2.413-1

Blue Jays at Yankees Odds

Spread, Total, Moneyline

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Blue Jays
21-26
+1.5
+1.5-177
o8.5-123
+115
Yankees
29-19
u8.5
-1.5+147
u8.5+100
-140
location pinTuesday 11:05 p.m.
May 19, 2026
Yankee StadiumBronx
thermometer image90°Fahrenheit
rain image52%Rain
wind image9Wind
Blue Jays vs. Yankees Expert Picks
Grant Neiffer
Grant Neiffer
Last 30d: 33-107-8 (+10.9u)
D.Varsho o0.5 HR+425
0.25u
Frank Ammirante
Frank Ammirante
Last 30d: 274-278-10 (+2.7u)
D.Cease u7.5 Ks-112
1.12u
Sean Zerillo
Sean Zerillo
Last 30d: 165-152-12 (-1.9u)
Under 9-115
0.58u
Bet to -125
Matt Trollo
Matt Trollo
Last 30d: 58-45-3 (+7.5u)
Under 9-115
0.58u
(B365) Adding with better line.
Under 8.5-102
0.51u
(DK) See Tuesday's article (Good to -115)

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Previews & Analysis

  • Blue Jays vs Yankees: Elite Starters Set the Pace article feature image

    Blue Jays vs Yankees: Elite Starters Set the Pace

    Matt Trollo•
    May 19, 2026 UTC
See more MLB Coverage Right Arrow

Prop Odds Comparison

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

No props found

Line Movement Tracker

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Public Betting Percentages

Away Logo

Blue Jays

Public

Home Logo

Yankees

23%

Bets%

77%

Money%

MLB Public Betting Right Arrow

Betting Trends

  • Yankees are 2-3 in their last 5 games.
  • Yankees are 1-4 in their last 5 games against the spread
  • Yankees are 13-14 in their road games against the spread
  • The totals have gone OVER in 3 of Yankees' last 5 games
  • The totals have gone OVER in 13 of Yankees' 21 last games at home

Matchup History

Against the Spread (ATS) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees		25-2312-913-1423-212-2
Blue Jays		20-2712-128-1514-155-12

Over/Under History

overallhome o/uaway o/ufavorite o/uunderdog o/u
Yankees		21-24-313-7-18-17-219-22-32-2
Blue Jays		22-23-213-119-12-214-14-17-9-1

Straight-Up (ML) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Yankees		29-1915-614-1327-172-2
Blue Jays		21-2613-118-1516-134-13

Last 5 Matchups

dateopponentscorespreadover/undermoneyline
May 18thTORW 7-6-1.5 LO 9NYY -172
May 17th@NYML 6-7-1.5 LO 9NYM +105
May 16th@NYML 3-6-1.5 LO 8.5NYM -125
May 15th@NYMW 5-2-1.5 WU 7NYY -147
May 13th@BALL 0-7-1.5 LU 8.5BAL -164

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Injury Updates

Blue Jays Injuries

  • Jose Berrios
    SP

    Berrios is out with elbow

    Out

  • Anthony Santander
    RF

    Santander is out with shoulder

    Out

  • Shane Bieber
    SP

    Bieber is out with elbow

    Out

  • Bowden Francis
    SP

    Francis is out with shoulder

    Out

  • Addison Barger
    RF

    Addison Barger (elbow) scratched Sunday.

    Out

Yankees Injuries

  • Gerrit Cole
    SP

    Cole is out with elbow

    Out

  • Clarke Schmidt
    SP

    Schmidt is out with elbow

    Out

See more MLB Injuries Right Arrow
Blue Jays vs. Yankees Starting Lineups
Blue Jays Starting Lineup
Projected
PITCHERW-LERAWHIPK/9
Dylan Cease logoRD.Cease, P3-12.411.18512.90
HITTERSAVGOBPSLGHR
George Springer logo1G.Springer, DH.196.277.3273
Yohendrick Pinango logo2Y.Pinango, LF.327.377.4291
Vladimir Guerrero logo3V.Guerrero, 1B.285.374.3783
Kazuma Okamoto logo4K.Okamoto, 3B.234.317.44310
Daulton Varsho logo5D.Varsho, CF.261.333.4275
Jesus Sanchez logo6J.Sanchez, RF.265.302.4195
Ernie Clement logo7E.Clement, 2B.283.309.4063
Andres Gimenez logo8A.Gimenez, SS.237.263.3955
Tyler Heineman logo9T.Heineman, C.150.190.1500
Yankees Starting Lineup
Projected
PITCHERW-LERAWHIPK/9
Will Warren logoRW.Warren, P5-13.421.16211.22
HITTERSAVGOBPSLGHR
Trent Grisham logo1T.Grisham, CF.166.297.3386
Ben Rice logo2B.Rice, 1B.298.400.66215
Aaron Judge logo3A.Judge, RF.266.398.59016
Cody Bellinger logo4C.Bellinger, LF.271.377.4766
Jazz Chisholm logo5J.Chisholm, 2B.237.316.3795
Ryan McMahon logo6R.McMahon, 3B.183.258.2833
Spencer Jones logo7S.Jones, DH.167.286.1670
Anthony Volpe logo8A.Volpe, SS.308.550.4620
Austin Wells logo9A.Wells, C.173.292.2643

Blue Jays vs. Yankees Odds Comparison

Right Arrow

Could not load odds

See more MLB Odds Right Arrow

Blue Jays at Yankees Team Totals

MatchupOverUnder
Blue Jays
21-26
N/A
N/A
Yankees
29-19
N/A
N/A